David Warlick Ryann Warlick Martin Warlick
Shakabuku Infographics Video

iPads make inroads in Triangle schools – Education – NewsObserver.com

From the newspaper article…

The News & Observer, Raleigh’s capital newspaper, ran an article on the front page of Saturday’s issue about iPads in area schools. iPads make inroads in Triangle schools ((Stancill, Jane. “iPads make inroads in Triangle schools.” Raleigh News & Observer 18 Dec 2010, Print.)) is a fairly standard and objective journalistic covering of contemporary technology in classrooms, with a fair inclusion of pros and cons.  What impressed me most was that the article got all the way to word 827, of the 1054 word piece before it mentioned digital natives.  As a personal experiement, I thought I would column out the pros and cons mentioned in the article and add some comments (in blue):

 

Positives

It’s tech: “Students using a “digital textbook, (for) a fast-paced visual tour of Gothic architecture, the feudal system and the Crusades.”

Durham Superintendent said.“You can actually dissect a frog on the iPad. That was amazing to me.”

OK, so iPads might make very interesting and compelling replacements for textbooks.  No argument there, though shame on us if we can’t go much further than that.

A Wake Forest charter school has been experimenting with 10 iPad this year. “Leaders have been so happy with the results, they recently made plans to order 20 more”

I’d like to know what those results are.  Can’t include much of that in a 1000 word article.  But people are invested in their schools through their children and through their own experiences as students.  We need to understand what success looks like today.

“..kids are telling us, ‘This is how we learn. This is what we want,’”

I believe that this is a much overused justification and not even a very compelling one.  It’s not because this is where our learners are.  It’s because this is where their world is and this is where their future is.  ..And continuing to insist on paper-based, packaged and controlled learning environments is as archaic as handing out stone tablets

“..young readers who record themselves reading aloud”

This is cool and geeky –but why?  Why is having students record themselves a better way to learn?  I would rather have read that, “Youngsters are recording their reading to be heard by younger students.  The readers are taking greater care with style, flow, and enunciation, because they are reading for a real audience.”  Again, probably too long.

“..used in the right way, hand-held computers can deepen content and produce effective assessments and better links to home.” Chris Dede continues, “If it’s used as a catalyst in those ways, there’s a lot of research that it is very powerful.”

No argument here, though the story continues to be a little thin.  Just knowing that these are the sentiments of Chris Dede is enough for me.  But there should probably be some link to Dede’s work at Harvard.  Go here!

Dede adds that,“..tablets are easy to use, lightweight and allow for small group work.”

Again, no arguments.  But I continue to believe that some of the best and most powerful potentials of media tablets for teaching, learning, inventiveness, and collaboration have actually been designed out of the iPad.

“(Students) like being able to type their notes and have maps and other references at their fingertips while in class.”

Again, why is this a good thing.  My answer is that it makes the learning experience more of a conversation.  When students have access to an Internet of content, during their classroom discussions, they are empowered to participate more fully and even more authoritatively.  Add to that the potentials of having students take notes collaboratively, and annotate each other notes, and you’ve got a new kind of classroom learning — a little more relevant to the future we’re preparing them for.

“impressed by his students’ ability both to work independently and to collaborate to solve problems.”

This is an important statement, because it suggests that one of the approaches we might be making is to simply give over the information technologies that are part of their ‘native’ experiences, and let them show us how they might be used — the new pedagogies.

Negatives

Michael Petrilli, vice president of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute says, “I don’t see how anyone would believe that throwing a lot of money at iPads right now would lead to improvements in this kind of school. This feels a little bit desperate.”

This is true. Simply putting a bunch of iPads in the hands of teachers and learners will accomplish very little. But I have to hope that professional development and continued opportunities and facilities for self-development will be part of the formula.

We must “..make sure the school’s infrastructure (can) handle all the machines operating at once. ..negotiate volume licenses and find affordable applications to install on them.”

A agree whole-heartedly with this statement.  But I believe that the position needs to be taken that schools that are not equipped to support contemporary learning technologies are relics, and not to be tolerated.

“Some say schools are asking for trouble if they spend millions on mobile devices and iPads that quickly become outdated. It’s easy for the devices to be stolen, lost or broken, said Rick Hess, director of education policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative think tank. He predicted headaches for teachers.“I think it sounds ridiculous,” he said. “This is the worst kind of thoughtless technology use.”

Basing your arguments solely on the isolated  possible and probable complications of giving information technologies to learners is lazy — and that’s the best thing I can say about it.

Anyone who suggests that teaching in this time of rapid change should not have its headaches to overcome, has their head in the sand.

Wake (Raleigh) “schools may buy personal computing devices for students and faculty in the four schools.. (but) ..not sure they’ll have enough money.”

If personal learner access  to contemporary information and communication technologies is the way to properly prepare our children for their future (and I believe that it is), then you find a way to afford it.  It’s your job!

Computers can open up new worlds to struggling students, Said Atkinson. “You can show, you can demonstrate, and you can give immediate feedback,”

True, true, true.  But I think we need to be  much more learner-oriented in our descriptions.

“Learners can find, see and interact with new knowledge, and have it respond to them.  This is what evokes learning for today’s children”

Again, I feel that approaching the advocacy of contemporary technologies in our classrooms should not be based on our children’s preferences.  I’d rather suggest that our children are growing up in a world where multitasking is a critical skill, and their learning experiences should reflect this.

My Conclusion

It all comes down to our vision of the classroom. What does it mean today to educate? What does it mean to be educated? There are three conditions that are shifting these definitions.

  1. We are preparing a new generation of learners
  2. Within a new information environment
  3. For a future we can no longer clearly describe

In this world, the definition of rigor is not how much you can be taught, but how well you can independently learn and what you can do with what you learn.

What I want to see in the implimentation of iPad programs is how students are utilizing their learning literacies as they engage in exploring, experimenting, discovering, and inventing in their world.

Comments

  • Anonymous

    The back story on the DPS Race to the top iPad proposal is that the new super attended the urban schools conference and APPLE did a great dog and pony show for him. No one from the educational technology department at DPS was involved in this decision. They still have not been consulted. This is another Field of Dreams moment. If we buy it they will magically figure out the best way to use it.

    So two schools will have new cool technology while all the rest of the teachers in the district struggle with their 7 year old laptops and classroom laptop carts that take 25 minutes to boot up-if they boot at all.

    • http://2cents.davidwarlick.com David Warlick

      It’s a common story that reflects and education system that is still way to top-down, especially considering the concentration of expertise near the bottom. It’s also sad, when there seems to be no promise to replicate a successful implementation across all Wake County (North Carolina or U.S.) schools.

      I wonder what the statistics are for Wake’s successful schools concerning the percent of graduates who went to college and the percent of those who finished in four years. My own observations of my children and friends of my children do not support the image of a high performing school district.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention iPads make inroads in Triangle schools – Education – NewsObserver.com : 2¢ Worth -- Topsy.com

  • Diane

    I really do see the potential of iPads in the educational setting. I agree that we must move beyond using it as a glorified notebook and work on helping kids collaboratively access and create content, receiving feedback from peers and working on authentic activities. That is a PD issue more than a device though. The intro of any new technology into a school must include professional development and a transformation of teaching to incorporate the device as a learning tool.

    My second issue is getting down to the nuts and bolts of dealing with the MANAGEMENT of the iPads. This include the purchasing and loading of apps, keeping up with updates, syncing the device and securing the iPad. For those of you out there working with iPads, how do to you do this? Is there a workgroup manager type of application you are using? Are you just letting it be a free for all, with educators paying for the apps on their own? How would we load in textbook apps?

    As a former teacher and now a director of technology looking to go 1:1, these are the questions I have. Anybody with answers, please let us all know!

  • D. Jefferson

    I too agree that technology motivates our students today.More importantly students are using technology on a daily basis. In the business world, technology is the focus.We are obligated to prepare our students for tomorrow. By doing so, students must learn how to use technology, as well as their brains. If we can use technology as a tool to expand their learning experiences and opportunities, we should do it.

  • D. Jefferson

    I too agree that there are both negative and positives to the new use of technology in the classroom. Overall, the positives out way the negatives. In today’s society, technology is used in business on a daily basis. At the same time, technology motivates students. Students are using technology in many ways. Our goal as educators is to teach, engage, and prepare. It is a positive experience to engage students through technology to learn. By doing so, students will be prepared for life upon graduation. Their classroom experience with technology not only prepares them for tomorrow but expands their experiences.

  • Pingback: iPads to be required in Tenn. school | NetFamilyNews.org

  • Pingback: Because the iPod just wasn’t enough…. | phochwert

  • Simon Terry

    Is it possible to connect an ipad or tablet type device (droid OS) to an exsisting LAN Based structure? At our school we use windows 2008 domain mapped devices for the students to store their files on. Can a tablet be connected to the windows 2008 domain structure to work with roaming profiles, shares and mapped devices? Anyone know? THANKS


Photo taken by Ewan McIntosh in a Taxi in Shanghai

RSS Subscribe

Search

Admin

Books Written

Cultivating Your Personal Learning Network
2nd Edition (2012)

Redefining Literacy 2.0 (2008)
Classroom Blogging
(2007) • Lulu
• Amazon
Raw Materials for the Mind
(2005)

Flickr Photos
Tagged with travel

www.flickr.com
David Warlick's items tagged with travel More of David Warlick's stuff tagged with travel
Teach.com
  • What I’m Reading

    MIT inventor unleashes hundreds of self-assembling cube swarmbots | KurzweilAI: MIT inventor unleash [...]

    Scientists test new archeological plane over Peru - Updated News: Scientists Test New Archeological [...]

    AMERICAS - In Peru, drones used for agriculture, archeology: In Peru, drones used for agriculture, a [...]

    Plutocrats vs. Populists - NYTimes.com: Plutocrats vs. Populists By CHRYSTIA FREELAND November 1, 20 [...]

    According to Newzoo’s 2013 Global Games Market Report, game revenues will grow to $70.4 billion worl [...]