TEDxBANFF is Now a Memory & I was Wrong about Creativity

TEDxBANFF, from the stage, about an hour before the kickoff. For some reason, I didn’t think to get my camera out, once things got started

I think I made a respectable, if a bit shaky, performance yesterday. After I was off the stage, I felt the same way that I always feel when I’ve done something for the first time — wishing I’d done things a different way and knowing that I will the next time.

I was fallowed by two other men (no women in the TEDxBANFF lineup) who talked about the future of schools and the magic of empowering unsuccessful classroom learners, and another talking about wind energy and energy literacy (Oh Gawd! Another literacy). They were all excellent presi-performances.

But! We were all blown out of the water by the 18 year old guitar player. Calum Graham has been playing guitar for four years, which was perhaps the most surprising thing that I learned about the young man, who’s performance epitomized surprise.

I had a conversation with the Calum before the TEDx about guitars — and I asked him, as one must, “What kind of music do you play?” He compared his style to Chet Atkins, I suppose because I looked like a Chet Atkins guy from his 18 year old perspective. I then told him how much I liked Leo Kottke, and he replied that he was probably somewhere between the country tone of Atkins and the folkiness of Kottke. After finally listening to Graham, I knew how uncomfortable he must have been with my question.

I do not know this for a fact, but I suspect, as a guitar player myself, that no one taught him how to play guitar. I doubt, also, that he spent a lot of time trying to sound like James Taylor or even Mason Williams (though he does a mean Calum’ized version of “Classical Gas”).

As I lay awake earlier this morning, trying to figure out what I’m going to talk about today in St. Albert and tomorrow back in Banff, and kept coming back to Calums performance, it finally dawned on me that he was playing the guitar. He was playing beautifully crafted and polished assembly of wood and strings. It was a mistake for me to try to think of guitar players I’d seen when I saw him on the lineup, because it was not trying to be a guitar player. He was playing the guitar..

..like he invented it!

You see, I was wrong yesterday, when I said that you had to have a goal in mind, a problem to solve, or product to sell, in order to be creative. I doubt very seriously that as Calum began teaching himself to play guitar, that he had any specific outcome in mind except the joy of making music. It was him and the instrument, and he taught himself how to get music out of the thing.

His hours of practice and experimenting for the joy of the effort, led to a performance and CDs that I know bring great pleasure to many people, and that joy seems to have led to a truly inventive (creative) way of playing the guitar.

It’s like I said to him, before he went on stage, “Surprise me!”

6 thoughts on “TEDxBANFF is Now a Memory & I was Wrong about Creativity”

  1. Hey David,I don’t think that you were wrong at all. It’s just that sometimes we create with the goal of having fun. Or with the goal of playing. Sometimes the goal is to make music or to enjoy playing music. And as Sir Ken pointed out Calum did create something of value because he AND others enjoyed his guitar playing. See, I still think you’re right. Just need to expand the goals.

    @educatoral

  2. All the moments of intense creativity in my life have come out of what can only be described as intense inspiration not because I was being motivated by external rewards or problems. These moments like Calum’s also were the result of practice and experimentation in an art that I love.

    Yes, I am known for coming up with unique solutions to problems at work but I think that is more because my livelong experiences of creativity have oppened me to looking at work problems differently.

  3. Guitar is my fourth instrument, and I’ve been playing it for about 4 months. I’ve taught myself to play instruments before (e.g., recorder), but I find with guitar I have a lot of questions for my friend. He says that I am teaching myself; I say that I’m mostly teaching myself, but he’s teaching me as well. It seems strange to imply on an education blog that someone can perform at Calum’s level solely through self-teaching. Sure, I’m mostly teaching myself guitar, but I’m also using method books written by teachers. Sure, I’m mostly teaching myself guitar, but I ask my music teacher friend for advice. Sure, I’m mostly teaching myself guitar, but someone already taught me how to read music when I took piano lessons at age 7 and euphonium lessons at age 14. Yes, I like Calum’s playing (and thanks for introducing him to us), but I doubt that his creativity arose solely through self-teaching. Surely there is a teacher or two or three who helped along the way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *