David Warlick Ryann Warlick Martin Warlick
Shakabuku Infographics Video

Only 6 Reasons Why Tablets Are Ready for the Classroom?

I caught this guest-posted blog entry in Mashable last night, as I was taking one last look at my Flipboard on my way to bed. ..and I typed a reply to a comment that was rather more terse than it should have been and that typically is my nature. But the issues are so important to me, that I thought I would post a longer response here.

The guest author was…

Vineet Madan is Vice President of McGraw-Hill Higher Education eLabs, which works with colleges and universities, professors and students along with technology partners to develop innovative, cutting-edge digital educational tools to improve the way instructors teach and students learn.

After citing an Apple oriented blog post on the success of Reed College’s iPad pilot (here is a link to the FastCompany article), Madan posed the question, “As we wrap up the first post-iPad school year, do we know enough to make the “fad, fail, magical” call? ..and gave six reasons why his answer is, “I think so.”

“1. Tablets Are the Best Way to Show Textbooks.”

Flickr (cc) photos from the Stanford EdTech

My initial response to this “reason” is, “Well yeah!” From a textbook publisher’s point of view, computers are far superior in their delivery of content when you factor in audio, video, and the ability to digitally highlight, annotate, and directly access a dictionary. This all looks great on the exhibit hall and works well in the classroom. But the mere delivery of content is an extraordinarily and dangerously limiting lens through which to seek the ideal learning device.

“2. Classrooms Are Ready for Tablets”

In my opinion, Madan did not make an effective case here, as evidenced by this comment on the Mashable blog post

..everyone knows that people will do inappropriate and not school related things on the tablet.

From the author’s argument, the reason should have read, “Tablets are ready for the classroom,” and I couldn’t agree more. But a classroom filled with curious minds and practically unrestricted access to a web of content and connections to each other is an entirely different place from what most instructors are accustomed — and restricting access to content and conversation are the antithesis of modern learning.  So I would say that many, if not most, classrooms are not ready — and this is something that we need to fix very quickly.

“3. Tablets Fit Students’ Lifestyles”

The argument here seems to be that students are lazy, weak, don’t like to pay attention, and shouldn’t rely on classmates to support their learning. But that said, I agree with the reason. Our learners in, while outside the classroom, are accustomed to rich, responsive, provocative, rewarding, and forgiving information experiences that practically define pedagogy. Learners should be engaged in similar experiences in their more formal learning environments.

4. Tablets Have the Software to Be Competitive

The more bristly part of me wants to dissect the meaning of <em>competitive</em>.  But instead, I will admit that I am not nearly knowledgeable enough about the vast array of apps available for iOS and Android devices.  My sense is that we still have a long way to go, and simply acknowledging that an iPad will work with Blackboard misses the far more interesting question.

Can Blackboard adapt to and leverage the potentials of a mobile learning landscape?

5. Tablets Integrate With Education IT Trends

It is true that tablet computers operate well within the cloud computing environment that seems to be emerging on many college campuses and increasing in the K-12 arena. But the question remains, are those cloud environment empowering learning and merely facilitating teaching? This may seem like a senseless question, but it isn’t.

6. Tablets Are Becoming More Available

This is probably true, if the iPad is the fastest selling gadget of all times. I must admit some surprise at the number of iPads I see at conferences, especially events for school and district administrators, and the device is barely a year old. But this is a non-issue to me. It isn’t education’s job to wait for availability. If mobile information and communication technologies are the most appropriate platform for preparing the next generation for their future, then it is education’s job, and the job of the society that employs it, to assure that those ICT’s are there — regardless of budget constraints.

I was too harsh in my comment last night. I seemed to completely dismiss the textbook industry, and that was unfair and unfortunate. I believe that we need their expertise and even their incentive to help reshape teaching and learning. But our efforts must not be limited to trying to make textbooks digital. Instead, we need to learn how a digital learning environment redefines and completely reshapes the textbook in a way that reflects how today’s environment is redefining what it means to be educated.

Education, as we most often see it, is designed to teach students how to be taught.  Today, being educated means having a broad and effective sense of the world, how it works, and its heritage.  But perhaps even more importantly, being educated requires the learning literacy skills involved in living a learning lifestyle — having been taught how to teach yourself.  Textbooks need to be platforms for generating curiosity, passion, and habitual learning.

Comments

  • http://davidwees.com David Wees

    David,

    I’m going to disagree with your last comment. We do not need the textbook industry as in many ways they are part of the roadblock that is making our lives (those of us who would like to see a change in education) difficult.

    Just because someone has power and influence, doesn’t mean they have the ability to influence change. Textbook companies are stuck in their old mindset, and trying to keep their profits up, in an age where information is practically free.

    David

    • http://2cents.davidwarlick.com David Warlick

      David, I do not disagree with anything you say here and believe that if the Texbook industry does hope rather than cripple learning 2.0, it will be because the industry changed a great deal — perhaps more than they are capable. But I’m simply not ruling them out yet.

  • http://www.nature.com/scitable/blog/labcoat-life Khalil A

    Tablets are definitely coming but right now they are just too expensive for the common student. With Chromebook coming up though, I’m sure many will try it out. We’ll have to wait to see what happens but it’s less expensive and should not be too much of a bother to carry around. Fact that it boots in 7-8s is a major win as it’s really easy and simple to just take it out, switch it on and take notes for instance. This ease and rapidity of access is what’s important. The closer technology gets in this way to paper and pen, the better.

  • http://twitter.com/morris_phil/status/70494524450938880/ Phil Morris (@morris_phil)

    Interesting comments/article on tablet computing: http://bit.ly/lXwSIi

  • Robb S

    I agree with many points you have made and tablets do proivde students with many more digital learning experiences. However, let’s not limit the tablet to the iPad. The tablet pc we have used in our school allows many learning options for the differentiated learner and for the instructor. I have seen students draw diagrams for their notes instead of writing text; they use OneNote to screenclip pictures from the web to supplement their notes … the students find exciting ways to use technology to enhance their learning experiences. I find the tablet pc offers many ways to enhance the learning of our students. I can’t imagine teaching without my tablet and I can’t help but marvel at the work students who show me as a result of using their tablet.

  • http://twitter.com/stefan_palsson/status/70740009568833536/ Stefan Pålsson (@stefan_palsson)

    Mashable: Tablets är redo för skolan, http://on.mash.to/j13dqe David Warlick kommenterar, http://bit.ly/luiGAN #entillen

  • Kyle

    Doesn’t it go without saying that the classrooms are ready for tablets. Of course it could be one of the greatest tools out there in the world of education especially the way that students are geared and what they are drawn to. In your last point you state that it is up to the education and the society that employs its job to provide this technology, when we can’t even keep good teachers in the classroom due to all of the budget constraints in the many school districts around the country

  • Stephanie Peterson

    I would not entertain the idea of selecting these devices or laptops for children k-12. I feel that they would not use them for purposes intended. I am speaking from experiences that has happened in my home. I feel that textbooks should stay within the system. However, all children would not abuse it, but for the most part I don’t think that it would be a good idea, especially holding parents responsible for their actions. But maybe in higher education it could possiblly work.

    • http://2cents.davidwarlick.com David Warlick

      Stephanie, there are a lot of schools out there that have gone a one to one configuration, where each learner has a learning device (handheld, tablet, netbook, or laptop) and in many of them, the learners take the computers home with them. The media has shared some instances of abuse and of schools not making the most effective use of the machines. But, by and large, these experiences have been quite successful.

  • MVR, Newark, DE

    Textbooks have some advantages over electronic books. They are:

    - Ability to high lite key points
    - Add side notes from reader
    - Use as a future resource and/or guide

    It seems that the ability to do the above is a necessary and advantageous process of learning (acquiring the information) for many students. Why not keep the textbook, use the textbook, but not as the only resource.

  • http://www.dunkenfrance.com chaussures dunk

    this is a great post,thanks

  • Pingback: Teaching and Learning with Technology » Blog Archive » Admission or Prohibition of Laptops and Other Technology in the Classroom by Julia Frankland


Photo taken by Ewan McIntosh in a Taxi in Shanghai

RSS Subscribe

Search

Admin

Books Written

Cultivating Your Personal Learning Network
2nd Edition (2012)

Redefining Literacy 2.0 (2008)
Classroom Blogging
(2007) • Lulu
• Amazon
Raw Materials for the Mind
(2005)

Flickr Photos
Tagged with travel

www.flickr.com
David Warlick's items tagged with travel More of David Warlick's stuff tagged with travel
Teach.com
  • Meta

  • Archives